Cottage Hotel of Mendon at 1390 Pittsford Mendon Road, Mendon, New York.

We went to the Cottage Hotel for the first time for Dinner on Saturday night. We probably won't be back. First, the good stuff. We all agreed that the entrees we ordered were good and what we expected and prices weren't especially high. However, the French Onion soup that we each ordered was delivered to our table lukewarm and wasn't as good when compared to other local pub restaurants. Also, service was a bit slow (even though the restaurant wasn't particularly full). And here's a first, I was charged a buck for a taste of a craft beer I wasn't familiar with. This has never happened in any other restaurant. Finally, I almost didn't get a beer refill until we reminded the server that it was waiting on the bar.